On the question of anonymity


Anonymity is a strategy used by many authors to express themselves freely on certain issues deemed subversive by the authorities or a given circle (denunciation of abuses of power, situations of violence emanating from institutions and dominant people, hate speech, compromising relationships, etc.). Anonymity is used to guarantee freedom of speech and minimise the risk of sanctions, whether legal, professional, or interpersonal, but does not prevent them.

In his book Domination and the Arts of Resistance (1990) the American anarchist and political scientist James C. Scott distinguishes “hidden text” and “public text”. He devises a template to think about dominant relationships: “Any dominated group produces, by virtue of its condition, a “hidden text” under the eyes of the dominant, which represents a critique of power. Dominants, on their sides, also develop a hidden text involving the practices and underpinnings of their power, which cannot be publicly exposed. »

Duplicity is the rule, but James C. Scott shows the conditions that can disrupt it.

One of them consists in the use of anonymity, where the messengers are masked, but the criticism, the message, can nevertheless be direct and unambiguous.


For example, when Nicolas Bourriaud, previously director of the Palais de Tokyo and the Beaux Arts de Paris, currently director of the Mo.Co and curator of the Istanbul 2019 Biennale, rises up against the authors of yesterday’s text on Documentations, notably because of its anonymity, one can wonder about the nature of the power relationship that exists between Nicolas Bourriaud and the voices that would challenge his authority. We could ask ourselves: when a debate involves Nicolas Bourriaud in the French art world, who except Nicolas Bourriaud himself can take on to express himself brazenly ?

If you are interested in the issue of anonymity in a context of domination, please refer to the literature recommended below:

–    Geoffroy de Lagasnerie, The Art of Revolt. Snowden, Assange, Manning. Stanford University Press, 2017.

–    Annika Bender, Death of an Art Critique, 2017, Sternberg Press, 96p.

–    Yaman Akdeniz, “Anonymity, Democracy, and Cyberspace” in Social Research, (2002) 69(1), Spring, pp 180-194.

–   Hans Asenbaum, “Anonymity and Democracy: Absence as Presence in the Public Sphere” in American Political Science Review, Volume 112, Issue 3, August 2018, pp. 459-472



  • Opinion
    GREETINGS

    To all those who wish to strengthen their vertical and authoritarian power they exercise only to serve socially and culturally conservative and reactionary interests, to all spokespersons trying to discredit dissident voices: Do not forget you are dealing with a crowd of ultra-precarized art agents who have nothing more to lose and who, moreover, have no GREETINGS


    Lire la suite
  • Critiques
    Komunuma, artwashing in the Parisian suburbs: The Coloniality of Cultural Democratisation

    While the Covid-19 crisis has exposed the major structural inequalities facing Seine-Saint-Denis, the only long-term strategy for the territory seems still to be ever more real estate speculation, ever more marginalisation and greater precariousness. A few months ago in Romainville, the property developer Fiminco inaugurated Komunuma, its latest artistic and real estate project. Based on Komunuma, artwashing in the Parisian suburbs: The Coloniality of Cultural Democratisation


    Lire la suite
  • Lettres
    Silence is Violence

    Two weeks ago, Temi Odumosu, a Sweden-based academic posed the question: Do we have the courage to address Black Lives Matter and to confront the prevalence of racism in Nordic art life? [1] The pronounced silence from Sweden’s art institutions would seem to answer with a resounding “no.” What is this institutional quietness? Do these institutions, art Silence is Violence


    Lire la suite
  • Critiques
    Why South Way Studio’s ideas Must Spark Outrage

    Although contemporary art institutions are facing growing contestations from decolonial, anti-racist, anti-capitalist, feminist, queer and environmentalist struggles, many of these very institutions and their leaders hardly make the effort to hear, let alone welcome them. From 23 June to 3 November 2019, the Musée régional d’Art contemporain Occitanie/Pyrénées-Méditerranée (MRAC Sérignan), an institution under the authority Why South Way Studio’s ideas Must Spark Outrage


    Lire la suite